Spin a Catboy Catboy Tier List
Keep what pays on the plot. Storage is not a tier.
This Catboy tier list ranks rarity bands, not a fake 40-name roster copied from another wiki. Mugpugs has not posted a complete public index. What we do have: Secret odds, a Super Secret note, a mention of about three Catgirls, and a badge for Harriet, a player-submitted cat. Until a full roster drops, ranking bands is more honest than inventing S-tier nicknames.
Place everything you keep. A Secret in the backpack is unranked. See upgrade the Base.
S tier — Secrets and Super Secrets
Secrets are the 1/100 Eclipse / 1/150 50B / 1/100,000 other-pack chase. Super Secrets are about ten times rarer than Secrets on the same crate. When one lands, it is S-tier because it is scarce and because it should become a plot engine.
Do not sell an S-tier unit to buy trash packs. Hunt more with Eclipse, not with panic. The method is on how to get Secrets.
A tier — high earners you can actually duplicate
Whatever sits below Secret but clearly out-earns the starter commons belongs here. You will know them because upgrading one of them moves the cash ticker more than upgrading three commons. Keep duplicates if you have pads. If you do not have pads, keep the best and store the rest.
Catgirls that land in this income band are A-tier too. The description’s “like 3 catgirls” line is a flavor note, not a penalty. They play the same economy.
B tier — solid pads
The units that fill the plot without embarrassing you. They are why cheap packs exist. Leave them down until an A or S drops, then replace from the bottom. Do not upgrade B-tier with money that could have been a 50B pack.
C tier — early commons
First-join filler. Necessary in hour one. Disposable the moment storage is tight. Sell or store. Do not get attached to a thumbnail.
D tier — unplaced anything
If it is not on the Base, it is D-tier regardless of rarity. This includes Secrets you are “saving for a layout.” Offline Earnings cannot see them. Place or it does not count.
Named exception: Harriet
The Freed Harriet badge text says “This is a players cat submitted on discord.” That makes Harriet a confirmed community unit, not a rumor. Rank her by the income she shows in your index, not by the badge glow. Badge completion is a collectible; pads are income. More on community submissions and Catgirls.
How this list changes
When Mugpugs publishes names, we will split bands into rows. When a patch retunes Secret rates, the latest update comes first. When Mutation Hunter actually mutates a band, the mutation list overrides the letter on that unit.
Use the pack list to decide how you roll. Use this list to decide what you keep. That split keeps you from opening Eclipse just to hoard commons with pretty ears.
If two units look identical, keep the one with the higher shown cash. Incrementals hide stats in tiny fonts. Zoom. The players hub is the lore side; this page is the keep-or-sell side.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common questions.
Who is the best Catboy?
A placed Secret or Super Secret. Named units are still ranked by income until a full index exists.
Are Catgirls worse?
No. They are a small extra pool, not a weaker economy.
Where does Harriet rank?
As a confirmed community unit. Rank her by the cash she shows on your plot, not by the badge alone.
Should I sell commons?
Yes, once pads are full of better bands. Early commons are C-tier on purpose.
Why is an unplaced Secret D-tier?
Because it earns nothing. Place it, then it is S-tier.